[Closed] News feed. Lot of empty space when video posted

+2
2020-12-11 • 1735 megtekintés • 15 replies

Let the video frame be bigger - for the whole width. There is no need to have so much empty space.

Volleybox 440
3 évvel ezelőtt
+2

It is a little bit bigger now.

The idea was to present whole box on the screen (without need to scrolling it).

Vitalii LatyshAuthor 81 11
3 évvel ezelőtt
+3

@Volleybox if the description is put under the video, the video frame can be extended for the whole width.

Anyway, who read this description if there is a video!, doesn’t it?

Volleybox 440
3 évvel ezelőtt
+4

@VitaliiLatysh descriptions added for most of the videos last time doesn't have any value. In most cases there are just advertising links to websites and probably most of users are just skipping the descriptions. It doesn't change the fact that I would like to read interesting descriptions.

@sitenoise @Sherlock @HappyWithVolleyball @Dorien @breakingice @JP @jais what do you think about idea of hiding descriptions and making video player full width? Personally I'm not sure about it.

It will looks like that:

sitenoise 334 9
3 évvel ezelőtt
+2

@Volleybox  I don't see how eliminating descriptions “widens” the video:
 

S…k 717 16
3 évvel ezelőtt
+2

Well, that's not a problem for me as I don't read 95 % of the descriptions. Most of them are not about volleyball but about advertising for the channel which published the video. It looks a bit less aesthetic though.

sitenoise 334 9
3 évvel ezelőtt
+2

When I posted that screenshot in the above message, I can't find a way to get the cursor below the image to continue typing something. Am I missing it? All I can do is type a caption. I can't get the cursor below the image

sitenoise 334 9
3 évvel ezelőtt
+2

@Volleybox  I think it “looks” better in a screenshot without the descriptions, but you know how I am about UI that looks better in a screenshot :) 

Frankly, I'd almost vote for showing only the descriptions and hiding the video. I want to know why the person posted the video, why they think I might want to watch it. 

Dorien 61 5
3 évvel ezelőtt
+2

As @Sherlock  and @sitenoise  already said, I would hide the description too.  We can often deduce from the title and "photo" what the video will be about. Nowadays every description is about the YouTube channel and not about the content of the video.

J. P. 135 3
3 évvel ezelőtt
+2

@Volleybox , I think that hiding the description makes it look like a spam of videos on the feed. I'm a fan of the descriptions when they dont really function as a description (since most of the info is already presented in the video title), but more like a publishers comment or so. But either way, I think this display is good and that it should be kept.

Vitalii LatyshAuthor 81 11
3 évvel ezelőtt
+2

@Volleybox still not filling the whole width.

sitenoise 334 9
3 évvel ezelőtt
+2

@VitaliiLatysh  I believe there is a resolution sweet spot, like 1280. You can see in the screenshot I posted above (unless I'm completely missing it) that the video takes up the full width — at ~1280xXXX. My screen is 1440 and looks like your screen shot. I don't know anything about the programming of dealing with that.

I notice a similar issue with wallpapers. The stretching stops and white space takes over. What is the resolution of your device?

 

Vitalii LatyshAuthor 81 11
3 évvel ezelőtt
0
jais 205 8
3 évvel ezelőtt
+2

I have the same opinion as some of the others - I would hide the description, because it's just YT channels. I like the idea that on the homepage there would be just a title and a video. And if you clicked on the video then you would be able to see the description too.

Or: Maybe there could be an option of a subtitle which would be displayed on the homepage, like the essential info about a video (who, where, when, against who etc.). However, this could just complicate the whole thing, which would not be a good idea… 

Speaking of width, I would propose to keep it as it is, because it looks more aesthetic if we have some blank space. It's better than to have everything filled up with stuff. It makes the page more transparent and easier to get through it in my opinion.

Volleybox 440
3 évvel ezelőtt
+5

Thank you @sitenoise @Dorien @jais @Sherlock @JP for sharing your opinion.

As a result hashtags are presented in the place of descriptions. They can say more than advertising links. Moreover we have an international audience and some part of them are not English speakers so hashtags presenting players, teams and tournaments names will be more understandable to them.

Regarding width, full width player (1013px) will make scrolling the website more difficult. I tested it. I would keep the width as it is now.

Vitalii LatyshAuthor 81 11
3 évvel ezelőtt
+5

Thank you all for your part! Will close the subject.

Röplabda játékosok rangsoraKi a valaha volt legjobb röplabdázó?Játékosok rangsorának mutatásaRöplabda játékosok rangsora
Ki a valaha volt legjobb röplabdázó?Játékosok rangsorának mutatása
0